There is no joy in Mudbugville. For now.

"There is no joy in Mudbugville. For now," by Mike Scott in, conveys the all-too-recent grief of New Orleans Saints fans with a handsome tribute to the memory of The Mighty Casey. Ever since 1888 "Casey at the Bat" has lent his tragic template to the sorrow of an epic defeat. 

Follow the link in the previous paragraph to Scott's sorrowful re-mix of Thayer's ballad -- and follow the photos of the dramatic Saints - Rams playoff game which inspired it. And for those untutored in the New Orleans patois--"mudbugs" are the same as "crawfish."  

Ernest Thayer's classmate George Santayana wrote in an 1894 essay ("Philosophy on the Bleachers") of the inherent drama (and potential tragedy) evoked by all athletic contests. Santayana noted (as did Thayer, in "Casey" ) "...the frenzy of joy of the thousands upon one side and the grim and pathetic silence of the thousands upon the other." Yet Santayana did not scorn this frenzy: "I cannot feel," he wrote, "that the passion is excessive."

George Santayana 1853-1952.  George shared with classmate Ernest Thayer a love of sports, but George was primarily a football fan.


Can Saints fans draw any consolation from the ancients? "Is there not some pent-up energy in us," asked Santayana, "some thirst for enjoyment and for self-expression, some inward rebellion against a sordid environment, which here finds inarticulate expression? Is not the same force ready to bring us into other arenas, in which, as in those of Greece, honour should come not only to strength, swiftness, and beauty, but to every high gift and inspiration?"

 "Is there any better justification for modern sports, even if that force intuited by Santayana only rarely elevates its participants and its spectators to those other, higher arenas? And as Mike Scott's "The Heart of a Who Dat" concludes: "Just wait until next year."  


Leave a comment

All comments are moderated before being published